I was asked to day if I could make dual-column reactions to the posts dealing with the art and writing separately. I'm sad to say that I couldn't figure out how to do that. However, I think I came up with something that might work to help me get to the bottom of what people like/dislike about my captions.
Basically, I changed the reactions boxes to the following:
I think it's pretty obvious how they're intended to be used. Mark whichever one you think fits the caption most appropriately. I wish I could do two marks per user, but I'm can't figure out how to do it. I hope this makes the rating system a bit more informative.